Fred, Smosh or Nigahiga - My Thoughts!
By Buck on Oct 6, 2008 in What the Buck Show
Who do you like better!? Here are my uncensored thoughts on all three!
Cheers (HA!)
London Buck
-
Find Buck!
Advertisements
Twitter Updates
Links
By Buck on Oct 6, 2008 in What the Buck Show
Who do you like better!? Here are my uncensored thoughts on all three!
Cheers (HA!)
London Buck
Speaking of Catherine Tate. . . (and me being a huge Dr Who fan), did you watch any Dr Who episodes with Ms Tate?
raineca | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
i looooooooooooooooooooove it!!!!!!!!!! ur soooooooooooooo much better then the ppl u r talking ’bout!!!!!!!!!! sorry but u r!!!!!!!!!!! mkgtweety
mkgtweety | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
I don’t really like any of them. Buck you should be #1!
I think Fred is really annoying, he’s my least favourite.
Smosh doesn’t deserve to even be in the Top 10, they’re not funny, they’re not really part of the YouTube Community and they rarely post videos.
The videos I’ve seen of NigaHiga is quite funny but I much prefer you Buck! :p
AnneFTW | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
Trust me, you dont have to feel left out of the humour loop with smosh, i dont really think its a youth humour thing, i dont find then funny xD
tbh i dont watch any of them, you’re the best!
seriously you’re like the only person on youtube that i know im gona love their next video every time
Daniefab | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
I completely agree with AnneFTW up there… I don’t enjoy any of them. The smosh guys are hot, so I am subscribed to them, but Fred annoys me [lol] and nigahiga is ok but not really my style of humor. I honestly prefer YOU [#1] and people like spricket24 and lisanova…
but that’s just me. =]]
luvthekellster | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
yeah, i agree with you. I enjoy Ryan’s videos the most. I subscribe to him and Fred. I am not a fan of smosh, I have tried to be but cannot. Fred has a good storyline but in reality, has no talent because it is just speeding up the audio. I look at it like this. It’s like the iTunes top 10 songs, they will have their high point for a while but eventually someone else will come along and get that number 1 spot…right not that just so happens to be Nigahiga and Fred while smosh is having a slow decline…
jryan9307 | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
loved your thoughts!
I don’t watch Smoosh or Nigahiga really, but I do watch Fred and yes is awesome!
faintinggirl | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
Fred is… to put it as politely as I can… not for me. He will NEVER be for me. EVER. Well, that is a little hasty. Maybe if he loses that annoying fast forward thing… I can’t even sit through one video because it grates on me.
Smosh… I’ve seen a few of their videos. The ones I’ve seen were ok.. nothing I get excited about.
Nigahiga I think is great. He seems like a really cool and funny kid. I am missing his videos. I hope he has a great time at college
TwitchyGirl74 | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
i didnt know you like Catherine Tate. I LOVE HER!!! cept i think they canceled it here
Billy | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
I like Smosh kind of. I like their older videos, not familiar with the new ones. It’s the only account out of 3 i’m subscribed to, so. I bet Nigahiga is hilarious but i just never got into him. He seems like a super-nice guy though
Fred, meh. I’ve watched some “episodes” but somehow i just didn’t get into him either. I love me some buck! hahaha, keep on doing what you’re doing cause you’re on the right track. I’m not saying that i laugh at everything you say but you make me feel good, so that’s amazing and i thank you for that. whee, oh this got terribly emotional. I stared from smosh and ended with a sob-story. oh well. GOOD LUCK IN LONDON, toodooloo. 
Liina
lainameryl | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
Heey Michael,
I’m also really into British humor. I think Catherine Tate really rose to greatness in the latest season of Doctor Who. Her performance in “The Fires of Pompei” was truely brilliant. If anyone would like to see some of it, it’s on youtube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ekWhOz8HBQ
And about the girl who plays Blair on Gossip Girl, Leighton Meester, her last name is Dutch and pronounced “Mayster” (just whippin’ it out whenever I can :P)
Thanks for sharing your view.
Martin
DevoidOfStars | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
HI!
i like how you just said you liked all of them and that was the end of it (yea right :D.) Haha, i like british humor a lot too. My friend recently sent me this show ( a internet clip cause i’m not in the UK, i dont think it’s on our TV) um, of the sunday night project (formally known as the friday night project) its a comedy/ talk show kind of like SNL only , personally, i like it better.
i deleted so much of this comment, i ramble too much! DARN IT! i’m going to stop now !
bye
DaWorldDominator | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
Hey Buck!
been away for a month its great to be home
its so good to sit here watching your vlogs again they make me happy
much love xox
PatrickBlog | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
I think Fred is just retarded because of the voice thing. I mean it is kinda intertaining but it is also just REALLY annoying.
Smosh used to have some really funny videos, but now they just kinda got worse and worse and worse. The life of ghosts thing has a few couple moments, but not crazy funny.
Nigahiga is my favorite. They have funny videos. I know they haven’t posted a lot lately, but they are in college.
A name not mention is KevJumba. Whenever he posts a video they are funny. He just didn’t make enough so he lost subs.
MuManiac94 | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
Hey I agree Fred’s videos are really funny.
Pinky8989 | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
I can’t really watch any of their videos but at least the Smosh guys are aspiring to something “more” in their videos and comedy. I can’t say that about Fred, myself.
LOL! I’m actually shocked you like Fred! I can’t watch it. The Clip Critics did a great video that pretty much sums up my opinion of it. They slowed down the video to a normal speed and what was left, was, essentially nothing.
I do wonder what Smosh has outside of YouTube. I can’t see any network picking up what they do online and letting it play-out on television… I think they’re the most realistic to break into mainstream old media though.
JasonERF | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
I love Catherine Tate-she was in Doctor Who!
My friends hate Fred, but I can’t help but laugh everytime I see his vids.
mynameisnotmaddie | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
WhattheBuck & Nigahiga are still my top favorites
girlgirl | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
Fred is the high-pitched-voice male Lonelygirl15.
Sometimes, it’s annoying to hear him, but then he makes me laugh. I like it when he sings. Or when he runs. Or when he’s angry. Or when he screams. But mostly when he sings.
Smosh should make more videos. I usually love their videos, but I didn’t like the Ghost videos much. I did enjoy seeing that they weren’t “dead.”
Nigahiga has funny videos, I can’t wait for the movie!
I’m subbed to all of them, and I don’t know who my favourite is.
CookieBites | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
I love Smosh… but I also looove Nigahiga… and sorry… never wathced a video of Fred. It’s because I don’t go to youtube everyday, and I really have to study, but I’m gonna watch Fred… I don’t know when… but I will! (Maybe I don’t know him because I’m from Brazil, and here youtube isn’t a great deal for everybody… only few people have fun watching videos… yeah… I think they’re crazy!) I agree with you, I think that Smosh is also doing something else with college, or work… or anything else, but I still think they’re very funny, althoug, they seem that they’re doing their videos by force, only their fans are always asking for new videos, but I want great videos, even if it takes a lot of time, and I really believe that they didn’t lost their great humor.
I LOVE YOU! sometimes I don’t understand what you’re saying… because I speak portuguese… but I always laugh!!
Thais | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
I don’t even know where Fred came from. Saw a couple videos because I saw them on “Videos being watched right now” and he’s had a lot of featured videos on the front page. However, I didn’t like the videos at all. It was just annoying to watch.
Smosh was funny a long time ago. Most memorable for me would be the transformers. I kind of stopped watching them though… Their videos just didn’t do it for me anymore.
Nighiga I just found out about today, and that’s actually how I found your channel. I must say they are already my favorite out of the 3. They have a great sense of humor.
Although none of them are actually in my top favorite people on youtube; nigahiga wins this vote.
chainace | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
Yay! You mentioned Bo Burnham. He and Davedays are my favorite youtubers. Out of the top three, I’d have to say that Nigahiga is the best. I don’t even subscribe to Smosh.
LaserOrange | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
OH MY GOD!!!!!!!!
UR VOICE IS LIKE DEEP ALL OF A SUDDEN!!!
why do you make ur voice so high on What the Buck?
i watched this and then watched What the Buck and (no offense) my ears started bleeding… w/e i still love you!
ugh nigahiga used to be really good, with their how to be videos, but now their videos are annoying and NEVER make me laugh….
WHO THE HELL IS SMOSH?
fred is my fave out of these 3 for sure he has great ideas. but i still dont laugh when i watch his vids…..
i guess it just takes some REALLY crazy, random, and stupid stuff to me make me laugh… even worse than fred…
btw- your like using big words and sound so intelligent and all…. its like youre smart and then your like… the what the buck dude.
cshmmg | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
the thing is smosh there trying to hard to be funny or there blowing it off.
Every body starting to hate smosh. Like I love there old videos the classic’s are always better. Im still a die heart smosh fan no matter what. But thay need to bring one or a couple kick ass videos and get back on track. Fred i so agree with buck i love the people in fred. But im not a big fan of fred. nigahiga thay made good funny how to videos in the past but thay cant always do there how to videos forever and there losing there touch. Im always tired of hering how people love nigahiga it drives me nuts!! But all the youtube stars are losing there touch at some point. But at out of the three it would be smosh, somthing about them im always driven to.
But right now my 1# fav. youtube star of all the youtube land is.. wastetimechasingcars and cadegostocollege. But there all funny!=D I dont hate any of them.=D
bbyo | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
i don’t like fred he is just annoying, nigahiga is my favorite of the three but my favorite channel is community channel and THEWHATTHEBUCKSHOW is a close second
enzvideos | Oct 6, 2008 | Reply
I subscribed cause you make me laugh XD not cause u were that popular i rmmbr the first one i saw was of the naked vlog i was like =O
lol nd i can relate to you cause i talk fast all the time which annoys people but i cnt help it
anyhooo love your stuff =D
nyz_91 | Oct 7, 2008 | Reply
I personally like smosh the most. They have had some pretty funny videos, but I agree, the life as ghosts episodes aren’t great, but they r ok. Some people here said that they post random. That’s not tie. Some people said they don’t post much at all. But really, nigahiga isn’t posting much at all. He may be in college, but guess what, smosh is too. I also really don’t like fred. I used to think he was hilarious, but now I think he’s just annoying and not funny. I’ve seen nigahiga, and they aren’t really that funny. Some funny parts, but I’m just not a fan.
austin68240 | Oct 7, 2008 | Reply
I don’t like any of them. Smosh is un-funny, Nigahiga is overrated and Fred reminds me of an ex-boyfriend, who looked and talked like that. Buck FTW!
harlequingirl | Oct 8, 2008 | Reply
The one I like most is nigahiga. I agree they are a little bit overrated but they are still funny! I guess I say they’re overrated because their videos are kinda amateur-like. Not really high quality and probably if someone else made an exact same video, it wouldnt be as popular and people may call it stupid. But most of their videos makes me laugh and kinda leaves me feeling good. Smosh… I’m subscribed to them but I really dont laugh all that much for their videos. Most of the times I’m thinking “ehh… that was alright” but their videos seem more professional looking. Fred, his kind of humor is just not my thing. I dont really see anything funny with his videos at all. Smosh, I still find funny from time to time.
dreamynights | Oct 8, 2008 | Reply
I love Fred!! He’s by far my favorite! I think Smosh isn’t very funny lately, and I’ve seen maybe…two(?) of NigaHiga’s videos, if even that many. (Sorry!!)
Kittyt | Oct 8, 2008 | Reply
I think that all of them are funny in some way!
I am subscribed to Smosh & NigaHiga, but not to Fred! I don’t know why, maybe because I’ve seen only one of his videos and it didn’t make me want to subscribe to him! I don’t know…… Maybe in time, I will subscribe. But not now!
Smosh–> I like most of their videos, but not all of them! But they have done a great job on all of them!
Baibuks | Oct 9, 2008 | Reply
Your my favorite!
TarynActressTaryn | Oct 9, 2008 | Reply
You’re not your. Sorry.
TarynActressTaryn | Oct 9, 2008 | Reply
Well, I used to watch all 3 of them every single day a while back. But they all bore me these days…I dunno why, they just do.
The only people I really watch on Youtube anymore are you, Charles Trippy and sxephil.
I love you guys man, it’s always something fresh and new and always funny to me.
.nuhhcole. | Oct 9, 2008 | Reply
Fred all the way! I can’t wait to see if he’ll post the movie City Of Fred on youtube! WEhat do you think?!
JonasGomezFan101 | Oct 9, 2008 | Reply
I’m subscribed to all of them, and I really do enjoy watching all of their videos, but lately like you’ve said and I’m pretty sure everyone else has written that smosh has gotten suckier and suckier and that the “life as ghost” trilogy thing was plain stupid. I’m a new Fred fan and I love him, I could really see him being a comedian or a sitcom star because he’s really funny and the character that he has created is comedy gold….plus it doesn’t hurt that he’s totally hot. And I LOVE NIGAHIGA he is just so lovable and funny it’s hard not to enjoy his videos even if it is just him talking to the camera.
kissmysass23 | Oct 10, 2008 | Reply
Hi Buck
I guess like all of them. I haven’t seen much of Fred’s stuff though, because his voice kinda ticks me off.
MickyNL | Oct 14, 2008 | Reply
I can’t pick a favorite! Ryan is really cool. Fred is funny. Smosh… has better get going making videos. They seem pretty cool.
love ya,
maddie
horsegal121441 | Oct 18, 2008 | Reply
NigaHiga is my fave, Fred is funny, I really, really don’t like smosh, but they’re hot.
GradientMac | Oct 20, 2008 | Reply
Honestly, i dont know who smosh is lmaoo ! fred && nigahiga are really hard to choose which is better because ive known freds channel for a lonq time && i just noticed nigahiga 3 days ago and im aclready attached but i have to say, nigahiga is better
his videos are so funny but the funniest things of his videos are the bloopers ! and i love the video that you && nigahiga did together . one of the best videos ;D
kaylee3435 | Oct 24, 2008 | Reply